The Sport Cave
MLBnews

Arizona Diamondbacks Ride Arenado's 2,000th Hit and a Record Comeback Into the Wild Card Race

By The Sport Cave Team6 min read

The Arizona Diamondbacks spent the first week after the All-Star break reminding everyone why you never leave a game at Chase Field early. They went 4-2 on the homestand, erased a seven-run deficit to match the largest comeback in franchise history, walked off two straight extra-inning games, and watched Nolan Arenado stack four milestone moments into six days — capped by his 2,000th career hit. At 53-49, Arizona is not catching the runaway Dodgers, and nobody in the building pretends otherwise. But the final National League wild card spot is sitting right there, the schedule just handed them ten straight road games against teams in the same scrum, and general manager Mike Hazen has until the August 3 trade deadline to decide what this team actually is.

The Week That Was: Cardinals Come to Town, Chaos Ensues

The second half opened Friday, July 17, with a 5-4 loss to St. Louis that felt like a leftover from the bad old days. Merrill Kelly gave Arizona five innings of one-earned-run ball, Corbin Carroll finally cleared a fence again — a two-run shot in the eighth, his first homer since June 17 — and Tim Tawa added a solo homer and a double. Then Paul Sewald loaded the trouble in the ninth and Ivan Herrera's sacrifice fly broke a 4-4 tie. Saturday was cleaner: a 5-3 win behind a strong Brandon Pfaadt start, with Arenado doubling home two against his old club, James McCann and Ketel Marte adding RBI singles, and Jorge Barrosa robbing extra bases with a sprinting catch in the eighth.

Sunday's finale was the one people will still be talking about in October. Eduardo Rodriguez lasted just 2.2 innings and coughed up five runs, and St. Louis led 7-0 into the sixth. Then the dam broke the other way. Geraldo Perdomo legged out the first inside-the-park home run of his career, Arenado tied it with a two-run blast in the eighth — career hit number 1,999 — and Max Kepler lined a walk-off double over Lars Nootbaar's head in the tenth for an 8-7 win that matched the biggest comeback in Diamondbacks history. As a bonus, the win clinched the season-series tiebreaker over the Cardinals, which could matter enormously in a tight wild card race.

Milestones and a Massacre Against the Athletics

Monday's 5-2 loss to the Athletics was the week's flattest game, though it produced its biggest individual moment: Arenado lined a double into the left-field corner off Jeffrey Springs in the fifth for career hit 2,000, with his parents in the stands after driving in from California. He became just the third third baseman ever to pair 2,000 hits with 10 Gold Gloves, joining Brooks Robinson and Mike Schmidt. "I'm happy to do it here. With a team that wanted me. It feels good," Arenado said afterward — a quiet dig at the way his St. Louis tenure ended before the offseason trade to Arizona. The rest of Monday was forgettable: Marte homered, but Jacob Wilson and Joshua Kuroda-Grauer went deep for the Athletics, Jeff McNeil delivered a two-run pinch-hit single in a three-run seventh, and Kevin Ginkel wore the loss.

Tuesday brought more free baseball. Kepler crushed a three-run homer in the first, rookie left-hander Kohl Drake gave Arizona five innings of one-run ball, and the bullpen still nearly gave it away — Shea Langeliers and Wilson homered late to force a 5-5 tie. In the tenth, the Diamondbacks loaded the bases with nobody out and Ildemaro Vargas chopped a single through the left side for a 6-5 walk-off, Arizona's second in three days. Wednesday was not close. The Diamondbacks bludgeoned the Athletics 15-5 behind a seven-run fifth inning and five home runs: Carroll, Gabriel Moreno, Arenado, McCann — the 100th homer of his career, part of a three-RBI day — and Ryan Waldschmidt, whose first career big-league homer also came with three RBIs. Kelly, back on regular rest, picked up the win to even his record at 8-8.

Standout Performances: Arenado's Week, Kepler's Knack for the Moment

Arenado owned the narrative: the two-run double Saturday, the game-tying homer Sunday for hit 1,999, the 2,000th on Monday, and another homer in Wednesday's rout. For a player coming off the worst statistical season of his career, whom the Cardinals paid to go away, this was the version Arizona hoped it was getting. Kepler was the week's other headliner — a walk-off double Sunday, a first-inning three-run homer Tuesday — and with the outfield thinned by injuries, his bat has become load-bearing. Perdomo's inside-the-park homer and steady shortstop play, Tawa's extra-base pop, and Barrosa's glove all mattered. On the mound, Pfaadt and Drake gave the rotation its two most encouraging starts of the week, which is worth flagging because the rotation, as covered below, needs all the encouragement it can get.

Where the Arizona Diamondbacks Stand in the NL West

Second place, and it barely matters. Los Angeles sat at 63-38 with an 11.5-game cushion over Arizona as of Monday, and two Diamondbacks wins since haven't changed the basic math: the division race is functionally over. The wild card is the whole ballgame now, and it's genuinely alive. After Sunday's comeback, Arizona sat just a half-game behind St. Louis for the final NL wild card spot, and the D-backs went 2-1 the rest of the week while holding the head-to-head tiebreaker over the Cardinals. MLB.com pegged their playoff odds at roughly 24.5 percent coming out of the break — long odds, but the kind that a hot road trip against fellow bubble teams can rewrite in ten days.

Injuries and Roster News

The injury list is where the optimism gets complicated, because it is long and it keeps growing:

  • Zac Gallen — on the 15-day IL with right elbow inflammation and seeking additional medical opinions, which is rarely a phrase that precedes good news.
  • Lourdes Gurriel Jr. — placed on the 10-day IL July 18 with a right adductor strain, his third IL stint of the season after ACL rehab and a hamstring strain.
  • Tommy Troy — right AC joint sprain from a catch at the Dodger Stadium wall; IL stint backdated to July 12, with the club hoping it stays short.
  • Jordan Lawlar — hamstring strain; he has appeared in only 12 games this year but is ramping up baseball activities.
  • Michael Soroka — glute strain; he has resumed bullpen sessions, and his return matters both for the rotation and as a potential trade chip.
  • Corbin Burnes and Justin Martinez — both progressing in Tommy John rehab, with Burnes back on a throwing program after a teres major setback.

The corresponding move for Gurriel was selecting right-hander Gerardo Carrillo's contract. On the deadline front, Hazen told MLB.com in mid-July he intended to buy — "I want this team to make a deep run in the pennant race and into the playoffs, and we're going to need to add players to do that" — with first base the glaring hole after Carlos Santana and Pavin Smith were designated for assignment. By Wednesday, though, MLB.com reported him undecided between buying, selling, or threading both. This road trip is the referendum.

What's Next for the Arizona Diamondbacks

Ten games, ten days, four cities, all against teams with playoff stakes of their own:

  • Thursday, July 23 — a single makeup game in St. Louis, essentially a wild card head-to-head with real standings weight.
  • July 24-26 — three at the Washington Nationals.
  • July 27-29 — three at the Pittsburgh Pirates.
  • July 31-August 2 — three at the Cleveland Guardians, wrapping up the day before the August 3 trade deadline.

Merrill Kelly put it plainly after Wednesday's blowout: "It definitely has some big implications on it." That's the whole thing. If the Arizona Diamondbacks keep playing like they did against the Cardinals and Athletics, Hazen goes shopping for a first baseman and this becomes a genuine wild card run. If the road trip goes sideways, the sell-off talk from last summer comes roaring back. Either way, a team that spent the week specializing in late-inning drama should feel right at home playing games that actually mean something.

Teams in this story

The Cave newsletter

The best of our coverage — one email a week.

Keep reading